No Ebola Billionaires: The KEMSA Scandal and the Architecture of Impunity
PUBLIC HEALTH • STATE CAPACITY • THE POST-COLONIAL CONDITION
No Ebola Billionaires: The KEMSA Scandal and the Architecture of Impunity
On 23 October 2026, Kenya's Health Minister, Aden Duale, stood before the press and made a promise. He vowed there would be no "Ebola billionaires" getting rich off the current health crisis. He reached back for the precedent. During Covid, he told the press, there were people called "Covid billionaires." Kenyans died, his mother among them, while others stole the emergency money. Some of those thieves, he said, are now running for President. He did not name them. The KEMSA scandal is the most well-documented corruption case in Kenya's recent history. It involves billions of shillings stolen, broken contracts, and hidden companies. Every government office did its job investigating the theft. But no one went to jail. Instead, the top prosecutor who declined to charge six officials got promoted to run the country's spy agency. The board chairman who promised to punish the thieves got a new job running another hospital. The taxpayers were left with the bill. The KEMSA scandal is not a mistake. It is the system working exactly as it was built to work. The system shows you the small guys so you do not see the big politicians taking the money. Duale's promise is not a real warning. It is just the noise the machine makes while extraction happens behind closed doors.
I. The Missing Money
Duale's promise rests on the last batch of stolen money. The government's auditor, Nancy Gathungu, documented where it went. The Ministry of Health gave KEMSA, the agency that buys medical supplies, 13 billion shillings to pay for healthcare for Kenyans. But only 8.5 billion arrived. The audit cannot find the missing 4.5 billion shillings.
The public ignored that missing 4.5 billion. That missing 4.5 billion is almost twice as big as the 2.3 billion loss that made the news on the KEMSA scandal. Nobody asked about it. The auditor could only count the 2.3 billion because KEMSA converted it into physical items sitting in a warehouse. The 4.5 billion moved as cash. Cash leaves no countable object in a warehouse. So the audit did not find it. It just disappeared in silence.
The law did not allow KEMSA to spend the healthcare money on Covid. KEMSA took the healthcare money and used it to buy Covid supplies anyway. KEMSA spent 7.6 billion shillings of the healthcare money on those Covid supplies. The government had no budget for Covid supplies that year. By taking the healthcare money and using it for Covid, KEMSA broke the law. Kenyans lost the healthcare they were supposed to get.
KEMSA bought things the public did not need. Of the 7.6 billion shillings in items KEMSA procured, stock worth 6.3 billion sat in the warehouses for months. KEMSA held 97 per cent of those items for more than three months. The Auditor General found that KEMSA bought the items above market price. Selling them at current value would realize a loss of 2.3 billion shillings. The audit found the procurement violated the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act of 2015 and the Public Finance Management Act of 2012.
II. The Small Guys (The Named)
The auditor found the financial loss, but the audit did not name the men who signed the fake papers. The anti-corruption police, the EACC, did that. The head of the EACC, Twalib Mbarak, wrote a letter naming three top bosses at KEMSA: Jonah Manjari, Charles Juma, and Eliud Muriithi. He also named two board members, including a powerful politician named Kembi Gitura. The letter said these men gave out fake contracts to suppliers.
The procurement board also looked at the contracts. The head of the board, Maurice Juma, found that the contracts were completely fake. The paperwork was signed after the goods were delivered. There were no public notices. The whole process was a lie. Kembi Gitura, the board chairman, stood before the press. "We are not going to protect anybody found culpable," he said. "Any such person shall face the consequences."
The agency suspended the three bosses. Everyone recommended they be charged with crimes. But suspension is all that they got. The system exposed the small guys who signed the papers, but the system did not send them to prison.
III. The Big Guys (The Hidden)
The audit documented the loss. It did not document who received the money. The government allowed the companies that actually took the money to hide. The procurement board found that KEMSA hid 23 contracts. KEMSA refused to show the board the paperwork for those 23 contracts out of the 102 companies that got paid. KEMSA hid these contracts from the regulators.
Parliament tried to question some of these companies. One company was called Leon Interior and Design. A nurse named Eunice Cherono ran that company. She told Parliament she won a 42 million shilling contract to supply masks. How did she win it? "I just relied on prayer," she told them. "God directed me there. I prayed and my prayer was answered." One MP asked her why God did not help her win a contract to supply vaccines. She said she would consider it because "it has come to my mind."
Another MP caught the timeline. The paperwork showed KEMSA gave her the contract on April 30, 2020. But she did not even apply for it until May 6, 2020. KEMSA gave her 42 million shillings before she even asked for it. The MP asked her to explain. The record does not show her answer.
The auditor's report supplies what her answer could not. "The procurement process was not initiated based on need assessment and planning." There was no plan. There was no budget. There were no rules. The system was empty. There was only money to grab. In that empty space, prayer was enough to steal millions. She confessed to this in public because she knew she would not get in trouble. When you know no one will punish you, you do not have to lie.
Joel Ndegwa, the Managing Director of Meldian Enterprises Limited, told the same committee that he sourced suppliers from social media. The firm received a KEMSA contract. The mechanism, in his testimony, was the internet. The pattern was the same. No plan. No rules. Only access.
IV. The Promotions
Parliament tried to do its job. The Public Investment Committee, chaired by Mvita MP Abdulswamad Sharif, heard the witnesses. Ruaraka MP T.J. Kajwang' and Mandera East MP Hassan Omar pressed the witnesses. The committee recommended that the KEMSA bosses be charged with crimes. The Solicitor General, Kennedy Ogeto, stood up and said the 7.6 billion shilling contracts were illegal. The Committee on Implementation, chaired by Budalangi MP Raphael Wanjala, ordered the KEMSA officials to appear. The KEMSA officials did not show up. The committee fined a Principal Secretary, Harry Kimtai, 500,000 shillings and then adjourned. The committee never met again on the record.
The case landed on the desk of the top prosecutor, the Director of Public Prosecutions, Noordin Haji. Haji had the power to take the KEMSA bosses to court. But he declined. He did not fail. He chose to say no. The Standard documented the decision. Haji declined to charge six KEMSA officials.
The KEMSA scandal happened under President Uhuru Kenyatta. Noordin Haji was the DPP. Haji declined to charge the KEMSA bosses. When President William Ruto took office, he nominated Haji to run the National Intelligence Service. Parliament approved the nomination. The High Court dismissed a petition that challenged the appointment and upheld it. Haji took the oath at State House. The prosecutor who declined to charge now directs the intelligence service—demonstrating how the illusion of political change under Ruto preserves the exact same machinery of protection.
The same pattern followed the board chairman. Kembi Gitura promised that anyone found culpable would face consequences. The Public Investment Committee named him and Joel Gesuka Onsare for alleged interference in the award of commitment letters. He never faced any charges. He left the Senate. The President appointed him Chairman of Kenyatta University Teaching, Referral and Research Hospital in December 2024. Another public health institution. Another board chairmanship.
The Solicitor General said the contracts were illegal. But the government paid the suppliers anyway. The 102 companies kept the money. The taxpayers had to cover the loss of 2.3 billion, plus the missing 4.5 billion, plus the 7.6 billion paid to the companies.
V. Why It Works This Way
The KEMSA scandal is not a mistake. It is how the system was built. When KEMSA was stealing money, it acted like a machine built for extracting money. It took public money. It turned that money into private wealth. It answered upward to the politicians. It answered nothing to the people—a dynamic rooted in Kenya's deeper crisis of tribalism and failed leadership.
This is not a new problem. It is the old colonial system. When the British ruled Kenya, they built a government meant to take money and send it upward to London. They did not build a government meant to serve the people at the bottom. When Kenya got independence, the faces in the government changed. The machine stayed exactly the same. The machine still takes from the bottom and sends it to the top through inherited institutional structures.
The accountability chain works perfectly. The Auditor General finds the loss. The anti-corruption police name the small guys. The committees hold hearings. The Solicitor General says it is illegal. And the DPP says no to court. Then the President promotes the DPP. The money stays where it landed.
Duale is making a promise today about stopping graft. The irony is that he refuses to name the Covid billionaires. He cannot name them. Naming them would mean finding the people behind the 23 hidden contracts. Naming them would mean finding the real owners of the 102 companies. Naming them would mean following the money all the way to the top politicians. His promise is not a warning. It is the noise the extractive colonial machine makes while it runs.
Fred Matiang'i, the Interior CS who chaired the National Emergency Response Committee on Coronavirus during the Covid era, has declared his 2027 presidential bid. Jubilee endorsed him. He is in the category Duale invoked, the Covid-era political figure now seeking the presidency, without being a named KEMSA extractor. The category does not require him to be named. The category requires only that he sat in the cabinet that oversaw the Covid billions, that the system did not hold him to account for them, and that he now seeks the office that would let him continue the extraction at a higher level. The system does not punish the political class. It promotes it.
MY POSITION
The evidence leads to a position I will state plainly.
I believe the KEMSA scandal is not a failure of the Kenyan government. It is the government working exactly as it was built. The system was built to take money without answering to the people. The faces change. The machine stays the same. Noordin Haji protected the system as DPP under Uhuru Kenyatta. William Ruto promoted him to run intelligence. The same machine, two presidents, one outcome.
I do not accept Duale's promise. It is a show. He is promising to stop new thieves while protecting the old ones. A promise built on a crime that was never punished is not a promise. It is noise.
I reject the Western story that says Africans are corrupt by nature and transparency training will fix them. The corruption blamed on African culture is the result of a system the West built, exported, and left in place. Telling a machine built to extract that it needs a transparency workshop is not a cure. It is an alibi.
I do not believe the KEMSA bosses are innocent. Manjari signed the fake papers. Juma did not advise him. Gitura chaired the board and promised punishment that never came. Cherono took 42 million shillings and told Parliament she prayed for it. Ndegwa found his suppliers on social media. They made choices. They took the money. They should answer for it. But they are the front. The big politicians sit behind them, holding the money, and no one holds the politicians to account. The system does not punish the political class. It promotes it.
If I had the power, I would tear down the machine. Not the country, not the flag, not the independence we won in the 1960s. The colonial machinery the flags were draped over. The system that lets people steal without consequence. The system that shows us the small guys while hiding the big ones. The system that rewards the prosecutor who refuses to do his job. The system that calls exposure accountability. I would name every part of it. Then I would dismantle it.
The real disease is not Ebola. The real disease is this colonial state that exposes the front and protects the back, and calls the exposure accountability.

Comments
Post a Comment